An Insight into the Duties and Requirements of a Judge in Model Aircraft Flying

The most important prerequisites are a passion for model aircraft flying and a keen eye for detail. Precision and impartiality are also essential. Since many rules and programs are written in English, it is helpful to have a basic knowledge of the language. In addition, you must be an active member of a model flying club to gain access to relevant courses and competitions.

The path to becoming a judge varies depending on the model flying discipline in which you wish to become involved. The first step is to take a judging course, which familiarizes you with the rules and programs. It’s also a good idea to sit alongside experienced judges and “score along with them” to develop a feel for the evaluations. In the past, this was easier when working as a “scorer,” but today judges usually enter scores directly into electronic systems. Nevertheless, the principle of “practicing with the pros” remains a valuable way to get started.

One of the biggest challenges is the dependence on the weather. Rain, wind, extreme heat, or cold—judges must be ready to perform in any weather conditions. Added to this is the need to maintain concentration throughout the entire competition, which often spans long days. A consistent scoring standard throughout the entire event is crucial to ensuring fair conditions. Last but not least, judges need to have a “thick skin,” as discussions with dissatisfied pilots about the scoring are not uncommon.

Interestingly, the ability to fly oneself is not a prerequisite. Many successful judges do not fly themselves. This can even be an advantage, since they are not influenced by external conditions such as wind or the difficulty of a maneuver. However, there are also disadvantages: Those who do not fly themselves can only point out mistakes to pilots, but cannot provide specific tips on how to correct them.

One of the highlights of a judge’s career is certainly participating in European and World Championships. For many, these events remain unforgettable—not only because of the athletic challenge, but also because of the sense of community among the participants. International assignments are usually by invitation. Often, you’re recommended when an experienced judge is unable to attend. These assignments are the result of hard work and a good reputation within the community.

Nowadays, scoring is often done digitally. The scores are entered directly into the system, which forwards the data for evaluation. Judges occasionally receive feedback on their work, especially at international competitions such as European or World Championships. However, it is crucial to review one’s own scores only after the competition has concluded to avoid influencing the judging criteria.

Those interested can contact judges directly at competitions; they can put you in touch with the appropriate organizers. Alternatively, the regional board or the technical committee (Fako) is a good place to start. The Swiss Model Flying Association (SMV) website features contact information and a calendar of events, including courses and informational sessions designed to help you get started. An upcoming important date is the judges’ refresher course on May 3, 2025—an ideal opportunity to gain your first insights into the role. Working as a judge is challenging but also rewarding. It is a role that requires a passion for model aviation, intense concentration, and tact—and one that is rewarded with unique experiences. ■

Daniela Schmitter, vocational trainer for design engineers (EFZ), member of MG Riggisberg, chief judge, and board member of Region BOW; judge since 1998

Matthias Bosshard is a member of the F3A Special Interest Group